• BEST IN STATE—Senior Courtney Schoen Lewis was named Best PR Student in Utah. Story
  • CROWBAR—Athletes compete in annual Crowbar backcountry race in Logan Canyon. CHRISTIAN HATAHWAY
  • HINDU FESTIVAL—Hundreds of Hindus and friends gather for annual Holi Festival of Colors in Spanish Fork. DANA IVINS
  • RAINBOW CELEBRATION—Holi celebrants joyfully paint themselves at Hindu festival. DANA IVINS
  • HUT! HUT! HUT!—ROTC teams compete in Ranger Challenge at Camp Williams. ALISON OSTLER. Story
  • SNOWBARD JAM—Boarders show their stuff on the Quad during Entrepreneur Week. CASSIDEE J. CLINE. Story
  • SNOWBOARD TRICKS as hotdoggers show off on the Quad during Entrepreneur Week. CASSIDEE J. CLINE. Story
  • WINTER A and the American flag over a snowy USU campus. WHITNEY PETERSON
  • QUADVIEW—A springtime view of the USU Quad and Old Main from atop the business building.
  • PRESS CONFERENCE—USU President Stan Albrecht briefing journalism students. CHRIS ROMRIELL. Story
  • HIGH-HEELIN’ IT—Men in high heels and their female supporters walk a mile to protest sex abuse. TY ROGERS
  • ELK PICNIC—Elk and humans mingle at the winter refuge at Blacksmith Fork's Hardware Ranch. CARESA ALEXANDER. Story

Planning commission reconsiders Smithfield animal laws

January 19th, 2012 Posted in Opinion

By Jessica Wilkinson

SMITHFIELD—Kris Monson, a City Councilwoman for 10 years, stood before the Planning Commission Wednesday night to propose modifications to Smithfield’s animal rights ordinances. “I’m just going to propose an idea,” Monson said. “If you don’t like this, I’m not going to work very hard.”

Monson’s presentation was an introduction of her ideas to assess the support she could expect during the course of her pursuits.

“If you have the right size property,” Monson said, “you should be able to apply for and receive an animal rights permit from year to year.”

Commission Chairman Rick Vernon disagreed. Due to ordinances passed in 1972, property owners are only permitted animal rights according to specific zoning regulations. So long as one’s property has been occupied by a certain species continuously since 1972, one’s animal rights permit is active and legal. In the event of a temporary absence of that species, the property owner’s permit is permanently suspended. Proof of the animal’s existence and habitation of the property is required if the permit is ever challenged, and permits are specific to species.

Property owners who purchased land after 1972 cannot obtain animal rights permits without proof of continual animal occupancy from former owners.

“It’s a trade-off,” Vernon said, about observing ordinances. Someone will always be upset, “but you have to follow the rules.”

Vernon explained the original intent of the ordinances was to begin industrializing Smithfield, albeit quaint and rural. The regulations were created as a filter to separate areas of agriculture from areas of urbanization. The goal was to allow the opportunity for either lifestyle, independent of one another.

Vernon recalls the intent of dividing the two; Monson hopes to encourage integration.

“I want to appeal to those people that want a little more back-to-basics kind of life,” Vernon said. “It would be nice for kids to learn where their food comes from.”

Commissioner David Price also opposed Monson’s idea. He specifically referenced open lots within Smithfield’s city limits that were big enough to accommodate large animals, and recognized that agricultural opportunity as the exact situation the ordinances regulated. He found it potentially problematic to amalgamate designated zones that kept animals away from suburban neighborhoods.

“That’s not something we want in the city, I don’t think,” Price said.

Monson’s request for reconsidering animal rights regulations was supported by the majority of the commission. Five of the seven commissioners agreed the issues Monson presented were worth her research and that her proposals were worth investigating.

“I feel like these ordinances were put in place to urbanize our town, but why can’t we keep that flavor?” Monson said. “I can have a garden, but I can’t have an animal if I want to. It just doesn’t make sense to me.”

The issues will be discussed further at February’s meeting, Vernon said.

NW

Tags: , ,

Sorry, comments for this entry are closed at this time.